The Best Bread Maker for Bakery-Style Bread at HomeThe Best Bread Maker for Bakery-Style Bread at Home

The Best Bread Maker

Or how to fill your home with the smell of freshly baked bread.
Sarah Idle
Words by 
Sarah Idle
Updated 
Jun 10, 2020
Sarah Idle
Words by 
Sarah Idle
Updated 
Jun 10, 2020

If there’s any better smell than freshly baked bread, we haven’t found it. It’s guaranteed to make your mouth water and your home more appealing to potential buyers (apparently, but don’t quote us on that). Once a bit of a niche item, if Instagram is anything to go by it seems like currently we're all whipping up homemade sourdough and banana bread.

Sure, doing it by hand fills those #lockdown hours, gives you bragging rights and boosts your practice for when you can next try out for The Great Australian Bake Off. But the best bread maker helps you whip up a delicious range of bread and dough options, quickly and easily. We’ve spent hours combing through expert testing and real Aussie consumer reviews to bring you Australia’s best bread makers.

Affiliate disclosure
Best for most

Panasonic SD-2501

Easy to use, capable of producing a huge range of bread and dough (including gluten-free and spelt bread) plus jam / compote, a 13-hour preset timer, loved by Aussies and the 3rd most affordable option we reviewed. No wonder we reckon the Panasonic SD-2501 is Australia’s best bread maker.

Shop now
Panasonic SD-2501
Top
Pick
Best for more

Breville the Custom Loaf Pro

The Breville the Custom Loaf Pro offers slightly less bread-making options than our Panasonic winner. But it boasts sleek stainless-steel looks combined with a smart LED display. It too can whip up gluten-free bread and jam, has an auto fruit and nut dispenser and timer and is loved by Aussies.

Shop now
Breville the Custom Loaf Pro

How we picked

We started with CHOICE, Australia’s leading consumer advocacy group, which had tested a good range of bread makers. This gave us a good idea of how some bread makers performed in lab conditions.

But we wanted to know what real Australians make of bread makers. To do that, we turned to ProductReview.com.au, Australia’s first consumer review website. 

This gave us a shortlist of bread makers that perform well in the lab and in Aussie kitchens. There weren’t that many, mainly because there don’t seem to be many bread makers on the Australian market. When we checked some of Australia’s largest online appliance retailers, like Harvey Norman, they only had a few available. 

To find the best bread machines, we considered a range of factors. These included whether they’d been tested by CHOICE (preference was given to those that had) and how many ProductReview.com.au reviews and stars they had (with the highest numbers of reviews and stars getting the bread maker bumped up our list).

We also wanted the bread makers to be easy to use, capable of producing a wide variety of bread and dough and to have a good spread of prices.

Armed with all these criteria, we came up with Australia’s best bread makers. 

Best for most -> Panasonic SD-2501

Panasonic SD-2501

Easy to use, capable of producing a huge range of bread and dough (including gluten-free and spelt bread) plus jam / compote, a 13-hour preset timer, loved by Aussies and the 3rd most affordable option we reviewed. No wonder we reckon the Panasonic SD-2501 is Australia’s best bread maker.

Buy now

Easy to use and clean, capable of producing a huge range of bread and dough plus jam / compote and loved by Aussies. No wonder we reckon the Panasonic SD-2501 is Australia’s best bread maker.

It has 15 different programmes, which includes 11 bread and dough modes. You can whip up basic, whole wheat, rye, Italian, brioche and sandwich bread, plus pizza bases, rolls, buns, croissants and French sticks. There are dedicated gluten-free, spelt and jam / compote modes. 

You can customise your bread to your needs, thanks to the 3 crust colour (light, medium or dark) and the 3 bread size options (medium, large or extra-large). It even has an automatic fruit and nut dispenser.

It has an up to 13-hours preset timer, so you can look forward to fresh bread when you get home. Using it is simple, thanks to the large labelled buttons and digital display. The Diamond-Fluoro coated-bread pan and kneading blade stops bread sticking to the pan. Which means it’s easy to remove your bread and easy to clean. 

It’s been tested by CHOICE and is loved by Aussies on ProductReview.com.au where it has 4.5 stars from over 200 reviews. It’s also a ProductReview award winner 2017, 2018 and 2019. It has a RRP of $269, making it the third most affordable bread maker we reviewed. 

Why buy the Panasonic SD-2501

15 different programmes

Including 11 bread and dough modes, which allows you to produce a huge range of bread items. 

Gluten-free mode

Perfect for anyone with dietary needs.

Spelt mode

According to Aussies, this is a big deal and quite rare.

Jam / compote mode

Now you can make the bread and the spread, making this an all-in-1 breakfast / bread making solution.

Customisation

With 3 crust colour and 3 bread size options.

Automatic fruit and nut dispenser

No more guessing when to add your fruit and nuts, this machine will do it for you.

Preset timer

Which you can set for up to 13 hours in advance, meaning you can walk into the smell of freshly baked bread.

Easy to use

Thanks to the large labelled buttons and programme options printed inside.

10 minutes power interruption

If your power goes off, this bread maker will continue working for up to 10 minutes.

Easy to clean

The Diamond-Fluoro coated-bread pan and kneading blade stop bread sticking to the pan.

Loved by Aussies

It’s a ProductReview award-winner 3 times over and has over 200 reviews, giving it an impressive 4.5 stars.

The not-so-good bits

Bulky

Although Panasonic claims it's slimline, Aussie consumers say its height makes it bulky and difficult to store.

No window

There’s no way of seeing inside to check your bread’s progress.

No removable lid

Making a thorough clean of the lid tricky.

1-year warranty

For the over $250 price, we’d expect a longer warranty.

In summary 

The Panasonic SD-2501 is an easy to use and clean bread maker that delivers a huge range of delicious bread options – from your regular bread to spelt bread, buns or croissants. It caters for speciality diets too, thanks to its dedicated gluten-free mode. Plus, you can even whip up the spread for your bread with its jam / compote mode. A 13-hour preset timer and automatic fruit and nut dispenser makes it worth you spending dough (sorry) on it.

Best for more -> Breville the Custom Loaf Pro

Breville the Custom Loaf Pro

The Breville the Custom Loaf Pro offers slightly less bread-making options than our Panasonic winner. But it boasts sleek stainless-steel looks combined with a smart LED display. It too can whip up gluten-free bread and jam, has an auto fruit and nut dispenser and timer and is loved by Aussies.

Buy now

For about $100 more than our Panasonic winner you could get the Breville the Custom Loaf Pro. Sleek stainless-steel looks combine with a smart LCD display to clearly show you the progress of your bread and the time remaining. It has 9 manual and automatic programmes, letting you whip up basic, whole wheat, crusty, sweet, yeast-free and gluten-free bread. You can also make pizza or pasta dough and jam. Its custom mode allows you to get creative by making your own recipes. 

There are also 3 crust colour and 4 size options. Like our Panasonic winner, you can delay the start and it has an automatic fruit and nut dispenser. Unlike our winner, it has 60 minutes of back-up power in case of a power cut. It also has a collapsible kneading blade which avoids leaving a hole in the bottom of your loaf. 

For RRP $369.95 (the second most expensive option we reviewed), it comes with a 2-year warranty. It’s been reviewed by CHOICE and has almost 100 reviews and 4 stars on ProductReview.com.au.

You might choose Breville the Custom Loaf Pro over the Panasonic because you prefer stainless steel and you want a smart LED display showing progress and time left, a pasta dough setting, 4 not 3 size options and a viewing window. For your extra investment, you’re getting less bread making options. It’s also slightly less easy to use with its mixture of buttons and dial. 

Why buy the Breville the Custom Loaf Pro

9 programmes

Giving you a wide variety of bread choices, including pizza and pasta dough.

Jam mode

To make the perfect topping for your bread.

Custom mode

Get creative with this mode and create your own recipe by adjusting the time and temperature.

Gluten-free mode

For best results for those with dietary needs.

Collapsible kneading blade

Which automatically folds in when the bread starts to bake, allowing the dough to expand and avoiding a hole in the bottom of the loaf.

Customisation

It has 3 crust colour and 4 size options to suit your needs.

Smart LED display

To see what programme is selected and how much time is left.

Preset timer

So you can have it ready when you want it. 

Auto fruit and nut dispenser

The machine will choose the best time to add fruits and nuts. 

60-minute back-up power

In case of a power cut.

Internal light

For easier viewing. It can be turned on and off.

2-year warranty

A decent warranty for the price.

Viewing window

So you can see what’s happening.

Good consumer reviews

It has almost 100 reviews on ProductReview.com.au, with happy Aussies giving it almost 4 stars.

The not-so-good bits

Stainless steel

This looks good but needs extra attention to keep clean. 

Buttons and a dial

Making it slightly less easy to use than our Panasonic winner.

Price

At RRP $369.95, it’s the 2nd most expensive bread maker we reviewed.

In summary 

The Breville the Custom Loaf Pro offers slightly less bread-making options than our Panasonic winner for over $100 more. For the extra spend, you’re getting stainless-steel looks combined with a smart LED display that shows you progress and time remaining. It too can whip up gluten-free bread and jam and has an auto fruit and nut dispenser and timer. But it’s loved by Aussies and offers a custom setting to create and store your own recipes.

The competition

These are the bread makers we liked the look of but didn’t quite make the cut.

Sunbeam BM2500 Compact Bakehouse 750g Bread Maker

Who says a bread maker should be expensive? Not the Sunbeam BM2500 Compact Bakehouse 750g Bread Maker – its RRP is just $119, making it the most affordable bread machine we reviewed. Because it’s compact, it fits well in smaller kitchens, but it still offers a great range of bread and dough options. 

There are 12 programmes, including French, sweet, cake, dough, pasta dough and jam. It offers 3 crust settings (light, medium and dark) but only 1 size option. Its gluten-free mode has been endorsed by Coeliac Australia as suitable for gluten-free recipes – the only bread maker we reviewed that has this mark. 

With minimal buttons, bread options listed on the lid and a small display, it’s easy to use. Like our winner, it has a 13-hour preset timer. Unlike our winner, it doesn’t have an automatic fruit and nut dispenser. Instead, it beeps when it’s time to add these. 

It’s been tested by CHOICE and it has over 4 stars on ProductReview.com.au, although this is from a limited number of reviews. 

Choose this if...

You want to spend just over $100 on a bread machine that’s compact, making it easy to store, has 12 different programmes (including pasta dough and jam), is approved by Coeliac Australia for its gluten-free mode and you’re ok with adding fruit and nuts manually.

Panasonic SD-ZB2512

From the most affordable bread maker, to the most expensive. The Panasonic SD-ZB2512 comes in at RRP $439. For around $100 more than our Panasonic winner, this model is stainless steel and boasts even more baking and dough modes – 33 to be exact.

As well as the white, rye and French bread plus pizza dough, gluten-free and jam / compote modes of our winner, you can make ‘rustic’ artisan bread full of your favourite ingredients (think cheese, herbs or veg), ‘rustic’ sourdough and ‘rustic’ scones.  

It too has an automatic fruit and nut dispenser, but it also has an automatic yeast dispenser to add yeast at the best time. It also has a temperature sensor which adjusts the temperature throughout the process for best results. 

Again, it has 3 bread sizes and 3 crust colour options, easy to use labelled buttons and a 13-hour preset timer. 

It too has been tested by CHOICE and has good (4.4 star) but very limited (less than 20) reviews on ProductReview.com.au. Even with the high price, it only has a 1-year warranty.

Choose this if...

You want the widest range of bread options available in an easy to use machine that’ll do all the work for you, including adding yeast and any fruit or nuts and adjusting to the best temperature. You’ll need to be happy to pay around $400 for these features.

Breville The Baker's Oven

A far more affordable option than our Breville runner-up, The Baker's Oven has a RRP of $149.95. Which means you’re getting less features and you’re swapping stainless steel for white plastic. But it still has everything you need to make delicious bread at home. It’s also quite compact, making it a good choice for smaller kitchens.

It offers 9 programmes, including basic, sweet, French, whole what, gluten- and yeast-free and dough, plus 3 crust colours. You only get 1 bread size, but the machine is easy to use thanks to the sealed and labelled buttons. 

It has a 13-hour preset timer and an alert to tell you when to add any fruit or nuts. It’s been tested by CHOICE and has almost 100 reviews on ProductReview.com.au, giving it just over 3 stars. 

Choose this if...

You want an easy to use, compact bread maker that has a 13-hour start delay timer and less than 10 auto programmes.

How we picked

We started with CHOICE, Australia’s leading consumer advocacy group, which had tested a good range of bread makers. This gave us a good idea of how some bread makers performed in lab conditions.

But we wanted to know what real Australians make of bread makers. To do that, we turned to ProductReview.com.au, Australia’s first consumer review website. 

This gave us a shortlist of bread makers that perform well in the lab and in Aussie kitchens. There weren’t that many, mainly because there don’t seem to be many bread makers on the Australian market. When we checked some of Australia’s largest online appliance retailers, like Harvey Norman, they only had a few available. 

To find the best bread machines, we considered a range of factors. These included whether they’d been tested by CHOICE (preference was given to those that had) and how many ProductReview.com.au reviews and stars they had (with the highest numbers of reviews and stars getting the bread maker bumped up our list).

We also wanted the bread makers to be easy to use, capable of producing a wide variety of bread and dough and to have a good spread of prices.

Armed with all these criteria, we came up with Australia’s best bread makers. 

The real cost of breadmaking 

A one-off investment in a bread machine should basically get rid of your weekly bread buying costs, right? Well, not exactly.

You’ll be swapping your weekly bread buy for buying quality ingredients or pre-made bread / dough mixes instead. These mixes contain all the dry ingredients, including yeast, which you add water to. There’s a huge range of mixes available, like rye, fruit loaf, sourdough, multigrain and pizza dough. 

According to CHOICE, a 1kg loaf of multigrain takes between 3-5 hours to bake and costs just over $3. (Note that CHOICE doesn’t explain whether these costs are just ingredients / pre-made mix or if they include the machine’s running costs, i.e. electricity.)

If you use a pre-made 1kg multigrain bread mix, it takes between 3-5 hours to bake and costs around $2.60.

In comparison, a loaf of wholemeal bread from the supermarket costs from $1.30 for 750g.

Important features to consider

From our research it sounds like for the best results, you need to do some trialling and refining of recipes and ready-made bread / dough mixes rather than relying on the features the bread machine is packing. 

Here are the most common features of bread makers.

A range of bread types

Every bread maker, regardless of price, should be able to produce a good variety of bread and dough. The most basic bread options to look for include white; wheat, whole wheat or wholegrain; sweet; and French / continental.

A range of dough types

Most bread machines should also whip up dough which you then shape and bake in the oven. This includes pizza dough.

Different speeds

A bread maker usually takes between 3-5 hours to make what you’re after. So, most of them offer at least 1 rapid setting.

Crust colour options

Choose a light, medium or dark crust.

Preset timer

Want your bread to be ready when you wake up or get home from work? A preset timer will do this for you.

Viewing window

By seeing the bread inside, you won’t be tempted to open the lid which can cause heat loss and a less great loaf.

Power failure protection

If there’s a power cut, or you accidentally turn off the machine, power failure protection will keep your bread maker running until power is restored. The bread makers we reviewed offered between 5-60 minutes.

Gluten-free mode

Manufacturers have become far more aware of dietary needs which is why all 5 of our bread machines have gluten-free modes. Only 1 of them, the Sunbeam BM2500 Compact Bakehouse 750g Bread Maker, has been endorsed by Coeliac Australia as suitable for gluten-free recipes. If gluten-free is a big priority for you, look out for this mark.

What you get if you spend more

Pay more, and you’ll get more convenience and more bread / dough options but not necessarily better-tasting bread.

Loaf sizes

The most affordable bread makers offer 1 loaf size. Pay more and you can choose 3-4 different loaf sizes depending on whether it’s just for you or you’re feeding the fam / flatties.

Automatic fruit and nut dispenser

Let the machine do all the hard work for you – it’ll automatically add fruit and nuts when needed, rather than you manually adding them.

Jam mode

For an all-in-1 solution, look for a bread maker that offers a jam / compote mode. Then you’ll be able to whip up your favourite bread products and the jam to spread on them.

Pasta dough mode

Although pizza dough mode seems to be a standard feature, not all the models we reviewed offered pasta mode.

Spelt bread mode

Because spelt bread uses spelt flour, which is wheat-free, it needs some extra attention for best results. Only our winner, the Panasonic SD-2501, offers this mode and although a step up in price from other machines, it’s still our third most affordable option.

Foldable paddles / blades

To avoid holes in the bottom of your loaf, look for foldable paddles / blades. This is a premium feature that we only found in the Breville the Custom Loaf Pro.

Custom settings

If you want to get creative, look for custom programmable settings which let you adjust the time and baking temperature. Again, we only found this in the Breville the Custom Loaf Pro.

The bottom line

Bread makers fill your home with a delicious smell and deliver a variety of freshly baked bread, whether that’s regular loaves, gluten-free ones or artisan creations, like sourdough. They’ll also whip up a range of dough, from pizza and pasta through to sweet treats, like croissants. They should be easy to use and clean and quickly become a kitchen staple.

We think the Panasonic SD-2501 is Australia’s best bread maker. It’s easy to use and clean and produces a huge range of bread (including spelt and gluten-free) and dough, plus jam / compote. With 3 crust colour and 3 bread size options, you can customise your bread to your needs. It boasts an automatic fruit and nut dispenser and a 13-hour delay start timer. Tested by CHOICE and a ProductReview.com.au multi-award-winner, it comes in just over $250. 

A good runner-up is the Breville the Custom Loaf Pro. Made of sleek stainless steel, it has a smart LCD display for easy viewing and has 9 manual and automatic programmes, including jam and pasta dough. It has a custom mode too, allowing you to make your own recipes. It offers 3 crust colour and 4 size options (1 more than our winner) plus a preset timer and auto fruit and nut dispenser. The second most expensive option we reviewed, it’s RRP $369.95.

References +